Ten days before Black Friday, the crossed-out price on your product page is the most legally loaded number in your store. The FTC's Guides Against Deceptive Pricing (16 CFR 233.1, in force since 1967) say you may advertise a reduction from your own former price only if you actually offered the item at that price openly, in good faith, regularly, and for a reasonably substantial period in the recent course of business; a price raised in early November so the discount looks bigger is what the guide calls fictitious, and the bargain advertised with it is false. The rules get sharper for the other kind of comparison: a "compare at", "list", "value" or MSRP claim points at what somebody else supposedly charges, and it is deceptive unless enough of the major sellers in your area actually charge that much for a comparable item. Add the Guides Against Bait Advertising (do not advertise a doorbuster unless you have enough stock to meet reasonably expected demand, or say clearly that supply is limited), the requirement that BOGO and free-gift terms be clear from the start, and the EU's Omnibus rule that an announced reduction must show the lowest price applied in the prior 30 days, and the picture is simple: your sale merchandising is an advertising claim, and it is auditable. This is also newly a machine-visibility issue, because AI agents can surface your compare-at value to shoppers as the "was" price, and Google requires the sale price you submit to match your landing page and checkout. Here is the full rule set, the Shopify mechanics that create accidental violations, the audit to run before November 27, and how to keep the urgency that converts without the claim you cannot defend.
It belongs with the promotion stack on this blog: the BFCM 2026 Shopify plan for the campaign calendar, the flash sale guide for discount-depth math, the Merchant Center feed checklist because feed and page prices must agree, the agentic storefronts guide for how assistants read your prices, the conversion rate optimization guide for urgency mechanics that do not need a fake claim, and the privacy compliance guide for the cross-border side of the same sale.

The rule set, in plain language
| Claim type | What the rules require | Where it comes from |
|---|---|---|
| "Was $X, now $Y" (your own former price) | $X must have been offered openly, in good faith, regularly, for a reasonably substantial period in the recent regular course of business | FTC Guides Against Deceptive Pricing, 16 CFR 233.1 |
| "Compare at", "list price", "value", "MSRP" (someone else's price) | Enough major sellers in your area must actually charge that much for a comparable item, otherwise the comparison is deceptive | FTC guides, comparable-value claims |
| Doorbusters and limited stock | Do not advertise unless you can meet reasonably expected demand, or state clearly that supply is limited; "limited quantities" helps but does not cure a misleading offer; rain-check duties vary by state | FTC Guides Against Bait Advertising |
| BOGO, free gift, bundle offers | All terms clear from the start: which item is free, size or variant limits, end date | FTC guides |
| "Limited time", countdown timers, "only 3 left" | The scarcity must be real; calling an offer limited when it is not is the specific practice the guides warn against | FTC guides |
| Announced price reductions to EU consumers | Show the lowest price applied in the 30 days before the reduction | EU Omnibus Directive |
| Sale price submitted to Google | Must match the landing page and the checkout price, with `sale_price` and `sale_price_effective_date` rather than an edited `price` | Google Merchant Center requirements |
The uncomfortable context is that enforcement has been thin: Consumers' Checkbook tracked prices at 25 major retailers for six months and found that most advertised markdowns were not real savings, that at most stores the tracked items were offered at "discount" more than half the time, and that for 12 of the 25 companies more than half the items were at false discounts every week or nearly every week, while noting the FTC has not enforced its own former-price rules for decades. Low enforcement probability is not the same as low risk. Your exposure runs through state consumer-protection statutes and private class actions, through platform and ad-account policy (Google's promotions layer flags untrustworthy strike-through pricing and timers), through chargebacks and marketplace disputes, and through the newest channel of all: an assistant that repeats your inflated "was" price to a shopper who then compares it against reality.
How Shopify mechanics create accidental violations
Most stores do not decide to mislead; they configure a field and inherit a claim.
- Compare-at price is a public claim, not a formatting choice. In Shopify you enter the original price in Compare-at price and the sale price in Price, and the sale display appears only when compare-at is higher. Merchants who use compare-at to hold an MSRP they never charged are publishing a former-price claim they cannot support. If you have no honest former price, leave the field empty; the discount can still be communicated in copy without a crossed-out number.
- The pre-sale price bump. Raising a product from $40 to $60 on November 1 so a $30 sale reads as "50% off" is the textbook fictitious former price. Three cases make the test concrete: sold at $40 since August, compare-at $40, sale $30 (defensible); raised from $40 to $60 on November 1, compare-at $60, sale $30 (not defensible, $60 was never regular); $40 for two days in October and $30 otherwise, compare-at $40, sale $30 (not defensible, $30 is the regular price).
- Variant-level inconsistency. Mixed compare-at prices across variants can hide the sale display on collection pages, which produces the odd situation where the discount shows on some surfaces and not others, and your advertising and your storefront disagree. Set the sale at the level you intend to advertise, and check a collection page on mobile after every price change.
- Automatic discounts versus codes. Automatic discounts apply themselves in the cart and checkout (a store can run up to 25 active automatic discounts) and are the right tool for a sale everyone gets; codes suit targeted offers such as a creator or VIP code. The compliance trap is showing a struck-through price on the product page for a discount that only applies with a code at checkout, because the page claim and the checkout price then differ, which is also a Merchant Center mismatch.
- Sale price left behind after the promotion. The most common post-Cyber Monday error: the sale ends on the storefront but `sale_price` stays in the feed, or the compare-at value never gets cleared, so the "was" price silently becomes next season's inflated reference. After the promotion, set Price back and clear Compare-at.
- Timers and stock counters that do not reset honestly. A countdown that restarts, or an "only 3 left" badge on a product with 400 units, is the scarcity claim the guides specifically warn about. If you use them, drive them from real data: a genuine promotion end date, and real inventory counts, which is the same data hygiene the Stocky export checklist and the feed checklist are about.
The audit to run before November 27
- Export price history. Pull every product and variant with current price, compare-at price, and the date each value last changed. If you do not have change dates, start logging them today; the defence for a former-price claim is a record.
- Flag every compare-at value. For each, answer one question: did we openly and regularly sell this item at that price for a substantial recent period? If the answer is no or unknown, clear the field.
- Kill the November bump. Any price increase in the 30 to 60 days before the sale that exists to enlarge the discount should be reverted, and the discount restated from the honest baseline.
- Check "compare at" and MSRP claims separately. These point at other sellers, so they need market evidence, not your own history. Where you cannot support them, replace with your own former price or drop the comparison.
- Verify stock against advertising. For every doorbuster you promote, confirm the quantity on hand covers reasonably expected demand, or add an explicit limited-quantity statement, and decide your sold-out behaviour in advance (backorder, waitlist, or substitute) so the promise stays honest mid-weekend.
- Align feed, page and checkout. Submitted sale price equals landing page price equals checkout price, with `sale_price_effective_date` carrying the window in the correct time zone. The promotions layer in Merchant Center is where strike-through pricing gets judged, and an "Untrustworthy Promotions" flag costs you visibility exactly when you paid for it.
- State the terms up front. BOGO mechanics, free-gift eligibility, exclusions, end date and time with time zone, and the return window for sale items, on the product page and in the ad, not in a footnote three clicks away.
- EU and UK shoppers get the 30-day rule. If you sell into the EU, an announced reduction must display the lowest price applied in the prior 30 days, which changes what your sale badge can say. The privacy and cross-border compliance guide covers the same market-by-market logic for data.
- Write the record. One page per promotion: what the former price was, when it started, the evidence, the discount mechanics, the stock position and who approved it. Keep it with the campaign files. That page is what turns an accusation into a conversation.
Urgency without a claim you cannot defend
The reason merchants inflate is that honest discounts feel weaker, and the data says the opposite: scarcity and deadline mechanics lift conversion because they resolve indecision, not because the number is large. So build urgency from things that are true: a real promotion end date and time (the flash sale guide explains why 6 to 24 hour windows outperform month-long sales, with roughly 3.5x conversion at the same depth), real inventory counts on genuinely constrained variants, real shipping cutoffs for Christmas delivery (the strongest honest deadline in retail, and the subject of the cutoffs guide), tiered or bundle value that increases the offer rather than inflating the reference price, and early-access windows for subscribers, which create the same fear of missing out with no pricing claim at all. Then measure the effect the honest way, with the metrics guide: conversion rate by promotion, discount depth versus margin, and refund and chargeback rates after the sale, because a fictitious former price shows up in those last two numbers long before it shows up in a complaint.
Frequently asked questions
Debutify team
Answered by people on our team
Today
Hi! Pick a question and we'll answer it right here.
Is it legal to show a compare-at price during a Black Friday sale?
Yes, if the compare-at value is a price you actually offered openly, regularly and in good faith for a reasonably substantial recent period. A price raised shortly before the sale to enlarge the discount is what the FTC calls a fictitious former price, and the bargain built on it is false.
What is the difference between a former-price claim and a compare-at claim?
A former-price claim ("was $60, now $40") refers to your own selling history and is judged against your records. A compare-at, list, value or MSRP claim refers to what other sellers charge and is judged against the market: it is deceptive unless enough major sellers in your area actually charge that much for a comparable item.
Do I need to worry about this if I sell to Europe?
Yes, and the rule is stricter: under the EU Omnibus Directive, any announced price reduction must display the lowest price applied in the 30 days before the reduction. UK guidance takes a similar position on misleading pricing, so a sale badge written for US rules can be non-compliant for EU and UK shoppers.
What should I do the day after Cyber Monday?
Set Price back to the regular value, clear every Compare-at field you used for the promotion, remove expired `sale_price` values from your feed so Google stops seeing a sale that no longer exists, take down timers and scarcity blocks, and file the promotion record with the evidence of what your former prices were.
Still have a question? Contact us
The discount is the claim
Every pricing field in your theme is also an advertising claim, and the ten days before Black Friday are when that stops being theoretical: the compare-at value you set on November 1 becomes the "was" price an assistant quotes on November 28, the doorbuster you promote becomes a bait-advertising question when it sells out by 9 a.m., and the timer that restarts every morning becomes the specific practice the FTC guides name. None of this requires a legal department, only an afternoon with a price export and a willingness to clear the fields you cannot support. Audit every compare-at value against your own selling history, separate the claims about your prices from the claims about other sellers' prices, match stock to advertising or say the quantity is limited, align feed, page and checkout so Google's promotions layer trusts you, apply the 30-day rule for EU shoppers, and keep a one-page record per promotion. Then build the urgency from things that are actually true: a real end time, real inventory, a real shipping cutoff, and a better offer rather than a bigger-looking discount. Shoppers are not comparing your crossed-out number to your claim; they are comparing it to what they paid elsewhere, and the assistants they ask are doing the same arithmetic with better memories.
Author
Debutify
Debutify is the easiest way to launch and scale your eCommerce brand.

